Tuesday, July 5, 2005

2am-after Live8

   Three days later, and the Live8 buzz is starting to recede, leaving only a question: will any good actually come of it? I understand that 26 million people, worldwide, signed an online petition. (At least, that's what organisers say. Bob Geldof having claimed that over three billion people watched the concerts, I suspect the size of the petition may be somewhat exaggerated as well.)
   And even if it isn't, what of it? What weight do you think the G8 leaders will give to a petition signed by approximately one half of one percent of the world's population? What weight will these world leaders give to the concerns of a group of bleeding hearts and artists?
   Likely, none. The simple fact is, the issue is far more complex than Bob Geldof and Bono would have you believe. Forgiving the debt to many African countries does not equate to helping their starving masses in any way. It is simply forgiving the debt to the governments of those countries, most of whom did not use the money for the benefit of their people in the first place.
   Misappropriation of first world aid and assistance is rampant in Africa. African Presidents sit in marble halls, like Kings, while their people die of disease and hunger. Any forgiveness of debt on the part of the G8 nations must be accompanied by the termination of all future financial assistance, unless safeguards can be put in place to ensure the money gets used as advertised. Said safeguards do not consist of, "we really, really promise to use the money properly this time."

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

You are right.  The money needs to be safeguarded to assure that people in need get the help they deserve.  I think what the concerts did was shine some light on the fact that people do want to see people helped in these nations.  But you are right, it is not simple - at all.

Thanks for your great, insightful, entry!
Dawn

Anonymous said...

Well said. Now I believe I can safely refrain from mentioning Live 8 myself!

http://journals.aol.com/easuess/madsecretary/

Anonymous said...

    You are so right, Paul.... If only it was as easily solved as forgiving the debt.  I truly do think that these people's hearts are in the right place, but if it was as easy as they try to make it sound, this problem would have been solved after the last go-round. Political and social change needs to come, or we are just throwing good money after bad.   Tina    http://journals.aol.com/onemoretina/Ridealongwithme

Anonymous said...

Yeeeeeeeah, but.....

Pink Floyd put on an awesome gig. Roger or no Roger. <3333333

<3 Rachel